The Wallabies Tight 5

[Invictus]

Unless you have been living under a rock for the past few years you should all be aware that the wallabies major weakness is at scrum and lineout. The bulk of the responsibility for these two areas falls on the tight 5 (that is #'s 1-5 for the uninitiated). There usually isn't a great deal of debate over who should fill these positions (most people get distracted by shuffling the deck chairs in the backs) which is strange as without a competitive forward pack the best backs in the world won't help you that much.

Rather than begin by looking at players eligible for the wallabies, I thought it might be informative to investigate who might be picked in the tight 5 for a world XV (so that we might have a benchmark to aim at for wallabies discussions).

So, what players are deserving of a spot in a World XV tight 5?

Brodie Retallick as one of the locks is the first one to pop into my head.

Other suggestions??

[Kev]

Try Alex Corbisiero at loose, mobile front row & helped demolish the Wallaby front row on the Lions tour, along with Alan Jones the Welsh tighthead.
Can't go past Paul O'Connell as an enforcer


Then move Stephen Moore to Tight head so Hooper can take the bench behind Nathan Charles as 2nd rake !!!

[Scozzie]

I think it's Adam Jones you meant at tight-head, but would agree with his selection (based on scrummaging ability though). Dan Cole from England is also a very good scrummaging TH (...much as I hate to admit that....??). Another good option at LH would be Cian Healy, again very mobile around the park.

For hooker I'd have Bismark Du Plessis, and would throw Etzebeth and Retallick into the 2nd row.

[1aahnoor]

There usually isn't a great deal of debate over who should fill these positions (most people get distracted by shuffling the deck chairs in the backs) which is strange as without a competitive forward pack the best backs in the world won't help you that much.

Rather than begin by looking at players eligible for the wallabies,

[maelkann]

These bots are getting smarter.

[GIGS20]

These bots are getting smarter.

Not a lot smarter, it sounds just like a front rower