The Ref

[BDAVEY]

We played well for once, there is no need to make up excuses with the ref. I just watch the last 5 mins and we got plenty of penalties, as well as the tahs, but we didn't use any of ours properly...

The first tahs penalty in the last 5 minutes was just Waughs brilliance, the second one was more of Waugh being cheeky and was slightly to the side, but Hodgeson was Isolated and pretty much ran into the tahs backrow.... It really didn't look that bad tbh.

Pleas don't reply with comments on how SANZAR should fire the ref because that is just stupid.

watched that game again........ I still cant see how u can go with the ref.the collapse scums especially was so picky and he ruined the game for all what ever teram u bat for. All corrospondence I have read question the ref decisions and keep mentioing how inexperianced he was...Jazza93 I hope 1993 is not how old u r.
Rollon Saturday nite trying to find out who is going to ref this game hoepfully Dickenson as he was on the trouch last week God help me and EWF if we get this guy as a touch line ref

[joblot]

No take - didn't notice it! Although if it was Dicko that called it, I'd be inclined to err on the side of ignoring it...

That said, it is often the case that an apparent obstruction as seen from the touch line might not actually be a obstruction if you're closer to the play. If the "obstruction" prevented the defending team from tackling the ball carrier then it needs pinging. Sometimes the depth perception from the touch line will allow for such a call that needs ignoring.

Are you a politician or a beaurocrat? Hard to tell.

[Ecky]

Choose your response:


(a) I decline to confirm nor deny one way or the other

(b) Why not try to watch a game from the sideline and then watch a replay from a good high camera angle? Then you'll see what I mean. Better still, get out there and referee a game.

[SinBin]

I have the solution!!!
I remember the good old days of playing rugby with rucking. If you were in the wrong spot you found out about it, and then got the hell out of there!

+1 Unipirate.

Lying on the wrong side was "self policed" by teams McCaw would look like this for a while until he learned..



There are enough camera angles in today's game for stompers to be cited

[Bronski Beat]

Folks, we have a big game on Saturday night. The ref lost us the Tahs match thats a fact.

We need to be at MES in numbers and unified to beat the Bulls. Our team needs us, now is the time to chime in and be one of the extra 20000 players needed.

We go into this game massive underdogs make no mistake, but stranger things have happened. The boys hear our support, run faster and try harder. This is possible.

We need crowd chants and totdal support in defence and offence, lets work hard for our team!

You are with us or against us.


That is all.

[BDAVEY]

Folks, we have a big game on Saturday night. The ref lost us the Tahs match thats a fact.

We need to be at MES in numbers and unified to beat the Bulls. Our team needs us, now is the time to chime in and be one of the extra 20000 players needed.

We go into this game massive underdogs make no mistake, but stranger things have happened. The boys hear our support, run faster and try harder. This is possible.

We need crowd chants and totdal support in defence and offence, lets work hard for our team!

You are with us or against us.


That is all.

They have the belief and mental ability to win they just need a f ken experianced ref!!! seroiusly they will go into the game confident in themselves but they cant make dumb mistakes inside their 1/2
Prediction: an upset......?

[no.8]

Why did the management see fit to organise security to escort him off the field?
Did they think he had done some crap decisions?
Crap enough for them to organise this escort in advance?
Jaco Peyper you we're very ordinary...

[Ecky]

Highlanders vs Lions in Dunedin
Referee: Stuart Dickinson (Australia)
Assistant referees: Kane McBride (New Zealand), Shane McDermott (New Zealand)
Television match official: Glenn Newman (New Zealand)

Brumbies vs Chiefs in Canberra
Referee: Jaco Peyper (South Africa)
Assistant referees: Paul Marks (Australia), Lourens van der Merwe (South Africa)
Television match official: Matthew Goddard (Australia)

Cheetahs vs Reds in Bloemfontein
Referee: Vinny Munro (New Zealand)
Assistant referees: Chris Pollock (New Zealand), Cobus Wessels (South Africa)
Television match official: Shaun Veldsman (South Africa)

Hurricanes vs Sharks in Wellington
Referee: Ian Smith (Australia)
Assistant referees: Kane McBride (New Zealand), Glenn Newman (New Zealand)
Television match official: Shane McDermott (New Zealand)

Waratahs vs Blues in Sydney
Referee: Garratt Williamson (New Zealand)
Assistant referees: Paul Marks (Australia), Angus Gardiner (Australia)
Television match official: George Ayoub (Australia)

Western Force vs Bulls in Perth
Referee: Nathan Pearce (Australia)
Assistant referees: Steve Walsh (Australia), Damian Mitchelmore (Australia)
Television match official: Steve Leszczynski (Australia)

There you are folks. I hope you think you got what you asked for.

[blueandblack]

...
Jaco Peyper you we're very ordinary...

"ordinary" is an overstatement.

[Patster]

So Jaco Peyper get's another game - his return flight must have booked for next week, sorry Brumbies...

[Ecky]

So Jaco Peyper get's another game - his return flight must have booked for next week, sorry Brumbies...

Yep - like I suspected:

after the refs revue panel this week, will he be dropped for next weeks fixtures?.......
Posted via Mobile Device

Not necessarily this week. But there will be (a) a review, and more importantly (b) an evaluation with a score to gauge his decision-making against some competencies/compliance requirements. If there's not much improvement in his next game then I think he might be holding a flag for a while..

[BeeJay]

We lost on Peyper. He deserves to be shredded.