We don't need a new comp: Fisher

Peter Fitzgerald | December 24, 2007 - 5:10PM


ACT Brumbies coach Laurie Fisher has questioned the relevance of a Super 14 revamp, saying the incumbent sides just need to play more attractive rugby.

SANZAR, the competition's governing body, has hinted at possible changes to the structure of the Super 14 within the next three years in a bid to keep it an attractive product to sponsors as well to prevent a player-exodus to cashed-up European clubs.

One of the suggestions was an expanded Super 16 competition; another was to allow foreign stars to Super 14 teams.

But Fisher disputed the necessity for such change, claiming the problems were not associated with the make-up of the competition but more the nature of play teams have adopted.

One of SANZAR's ideas in regard to expansion is introducing a Melbourne-based side for Argentine and Pacific Island players - which could pave the way for Argentina to enter the Tri Nations in years to come.

Fisher was unconvinced the changes would improve the Super 14.

"It's a good comp as it is so whether it needs a revamp or we just need to play better footy is debatable,"he said. "Bringing an additional team in, is that a revamp? Does more teams make it better?"

I don't see how two new teams adds more quality to the competition."

The Super 14's broadcast agreement with News Corporation ends at the completion of the 2009 season. The renegotiation promises to be one of the most vital in Australian sports history as rugby battles with rival football codes for exposure. The ARU and SANZAR are well aware of the importance of rugby success in the next two years and believe revamping the Super 14 and potentially the Tri Nations would play a vital role in gaining the best media deal.

The prospect of having international stars playing for rival club sides has the backing of SANZAR. The proposal would allow franchises to sign a marquee player from another country who would then still be allowed to return to their home nation for the international season.

But Fisher again questioned the relevance of the plan, saying it would only further hinder the progress of the Australian national side.

"I dont think we should have one-off players looking to make good money when we could instead develop our own players personally," the coach said.

Fisher's Brumbies are in the middle of a 12-day break. Their first Super 14 trial match for 2008 is against the NSW Waratahs in Gosford on February 1, two weeks before their season-opener against the Canterbury Crusaders in Christchurch.