0
![Not allowed!](images/buttons/down_dis.png)
![Not allowed!](images/buttons/up_dis.png)
You're not linking Deans to the demise of the ARC though are you MI5???
"Bloody oath we did!"
Nathan Sharpe, Legend.
I think we are all in agreement re the 2nd tier competition. All those except the Sydney Comp boys.
The Sydney Competition has its own problems at present with a very lopsided competition. More fall out on this as the season progresses I suspect.
It is a bit of a pity, but not unexpected. This was the year of opportunities for him to stick his hand up and he didn't really show himself ready for a regular Super gig. To be honest, I thought DHP fell into the same category and wonder whether he would be doing the same were he not local...
Nah, nothing like that Burgs. I think Deans wanted to make sure that potential internationals got access to a decent level of competition in an attempt to develop them, especially if they weren't getting time in the Super 14/15 comp. Since there is no 'second teir' and the Sydney comp is arguably the best 'local' comp in Aus then it becomes the only place to blood new talent.
The problem with this is that our local comp becomes less competitive as a result.
More than just out the window.....Kieran was reportedly hating playing and living in Sydney and would've given his right arm to come back home, but needed to stay there for his 'rugby future'
At least that's what I heard, Maybe Josh was directed to the Sydney club scene Darko!
C'mon the![]()
![]()
You should be honored every time he plays for your club. He is way to good for the WA comp and would probably develop faster if he played all those games that he did for kala, in the Sydney comp with the tahs and brumbies reserve players.
And saying we should only recruit guys who will make it into the wallabies, while saying we need to recruit guys who can play club rugby all year round is a bit hypocritical![]()
Maybe I've had one or two too many to drink but why exactly does this article mean he isn't playing for the Force in the future?
He hasn't signed on the Highlanders he's signed on for Otago in the ANZC hasn't he? So he could still play in the Super 14 for the Force.
Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast.
Was wondering that a little too James.
I realise that they wouldn't want to be spruiking about losing players, but I feel the Force have always been a bit slack on keeping the Members, if not wider fanbase, up to date on player movements.
If you are reading folks, I think two valuable additions to your website, even if in a Members only area, would be a injury list including return to fitness status and a contract status list (ie date signed, club contracted from, number of seasons contracted, number of seasons remaining and Full v Academy, date depated, club contracted to etc).
Last edited by Burgs; 15-05-10 at 11:49.
"Bloody oath we did!"
Nathan Sharpe, Legend.
I'm afraid not GIGS- very different. I don't know where he was born but Josh Tatupu, on the basis of the last 3 years residency, is eligible for the Wallabies. James Parsons is not and wouldn't be for three years. Parsons couldn't be signed because the rules of a development marquee players are such that the player needs to stay in Australia and play in a local comp (whether that's an element of residency or just the ARU's rule I don't know).
There seems to be no valid reason why a Force player couldn't play in the ANZC and then return to the Force the next year. In our first season the Force were keen to get Tim Davidson over playing in the NZ comp and although the ARU were really pissed off there wasn't anything they could do. For the record, Davidson didn't end up going.
Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast.
Thanks to those that made pleasant comments about Josh. I know he will miss Perth and the friends he made there very much.
Let me assure those others that may consider him a mercenary,....... he is not. He played in Sydney because he was told to. Most people would prefer not to fly across the country and play with guys you don't really know, haven't trained with, stay in a motel and fly home after a game, however they do because their employer tells them to.
Regardless, the Sydney top club comp is well above that of the WA.
Josh's manager was approached by EWF initially as cover for Junior. This year I thought he would get a little more time, sadly that didn't occur and he needs to be playing a the highest level he is capable of. The New Zeand NPC is only a snip below S14 and has a fantastic following as it has that provenical feel that S14 lacks.
I for one will find it hard to support Otago (EWF was easy to support).
Rest assured that Josh has enjoyed his time in WA but needs to be playing. Remember that he has always been a gentlemen and been a good advertisemet for all that is wholesome about our game.
I will still wear my WF colours with pride and have thoroughly enjoyed this site. Take care one and all and I'll be watching with interest.
so your activity will reduce now that Josh isn't around?
bloody Mercenary![]()
C'mon the![]()
![]()